| Year | Team | Club |
| 1993 | J Wyper, J Berry, B O’brien, B Wood | Kurri |
| 1994 | S Lill, N Vasilakis, R Beavis, S Mcintyre | Maitland |
| 1995 | G Mears, D Mctaggart, L Pascoe, J Matthews | Muswellbrook |
| 1996 | D Graham, J Beverage, J Callaghan, P Osland | Kurri |
| 1997 | R Wilton, M Tracey, P Wilton, J Lane | Branxton |
| 1998 | J Partridge, A Partridge, K Barnes, M Hanly | Muswellbrook |
| 1999 | J Durham, N Simpson, G Eade, J Fitzpatrick | Muswellbrook |
| 2000 | S Edwards, T Tarrant, D Peachey, G Mears | Muswellbrook |
| 2001 | S Heffernan, D Curry, M Curry, A Black | Westside |
| 2002 | S Heffernan, D Curry, M Curry, M Brooker | Westside |
| 2003 | L Brokate, R Banks, P Marshall, R Bennett | Scone |
| 2004 | M Herbert, M Brittan, R Pink, J Stephen | Heritage Green |
| 2005 | K Pascoe, R Dial, S Gagelar, R Glover | Muswellbrook |
| 2006 | P Smart, J Smart, J Smart, C Cooper | Scone |
| 2007 | R Dial, G Tearle, W Marshall, G Thomas | Muswellbrook |
| 2008 | A Lucas, T Lucas, A Lucas, M Reike | Kurri |
| 2009 | M Hale, G Marcheff, P Callingham, M Ross | Branxton – Singleton |
| 2010 | B Mainey, A Mctaggart, R Murray, P Carey | Muswellbrook |
| 2011 | J Knott, M Farley, P Fitzsimmons, N Peace | The Vintage |
| 2012 | J Knott, R Logue, S Ling, A Ling | Stonebridge |
| 2013 | J Barrett, M Hopley, R Rutherford, M Ervin | Stonebridge |
| 2014 | D Storey, L Storey, L Smith, R. Janssen | Singleton |
| 2015 | D Perry, J Knott, S Leathley, Z Leathley | The Vintage |
| 2016 | D. Condran, B. Ling, S. Ling, B. Rourke | The Vintage, Cessnock & Hunter Valley |
| 2017 | A. Jackson, S. Knott, P. Mason, S. Vowles | Cessnock |
| 2018 | C.Small, B.Huckstadt, K.Wells, B Jones | Maitland |
| 2019 | J. Templeton, Z. Harris, G. Turner, L. Waters | The Vintage |
| 2020 | NOT PLAYED | COVID-19 |
| 2021 | J. Teague, J. Harrison, W. Headley, J. Noble | Scone |
